REDACT introduces a systematically controlled multilingual benchmark for personally identifiable information detection, featuring 51 entity types, 4,127 surface-form patterns, and 25 languages. It evaluates five detectors across 1,000 records, revealing that rule-based models fail on high-stakes data while LLMs perform better, especially in high-sensitivity categories. A reference-free LLM assessment confirms sensitivity-tier assignment as the most challenging evaluation axis.