This study introduces the Complex Social Behavior (CSB) dataset, containing 100 images of complex social interactions, to evaluate vision-language models over a decade (2017-2025). The research analyzes five visual-cognitive error types across four pre-Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) and five MLLMs.

  • Pre-MLLMs achieved lower accuracy than bottom-ranked human descriptions, while MLLMs matched top-ranked humans.
  • MLLMs eliminated the accuracy gap between simple MS-COCO scenes and complex CSB scenes.
  • Detection, recognition, and hallucination errors were found to have the highest impact on scene description accuracy.
  • Spatial dependence errors remain the only significant error type for MLLMs in this evaluation.

The findings provide a more thorough evaluation of how visual language models have advanced, showing that MLLMs have almost eliminated most error types except for spatial dependence.